Out 2nd Amendment Rights
by Lisa Dean
NewsMax.com - The Internet is the only free
uncensored system of communication in this country. Talk radio would come in a
close second but there are many restrictions on the types of topics that can be
covered, limitations on the number of times individuals can participate,
restrictions from government on the radio stations themselves. And, of course,
at any moment a talk station today carrying Rush Limbaugh and Dr. Laura and a
host of popular local talk show folks can tomorrow turn into an acid rocker
station with 24 hours of head-banging or what some claim is music.
That is why knowing who controls the Internet
and what their policies are becomes very important. For the last year or so, the
800-pound gorilla of the Internet in the US is America On Line. With 22 million
subscribers it dominates everyone else in the field. That is why it is extremely
disturbing that AOL has adopted a policy that treats guns and ammunition the
same as child pornography and pedophilia. If you try to buy or sell live ammo
from your AOL account you will be monitored and eventually you will be warned
and if you don't cease and desist, then your account will be closed.
Last year AOL sent an email to one of its
customers, a licensed firearms dealer saying:
"We have become aware of a web page site
that is part of your account. This web page violates Hometown AOL's Community
Standards, which prohibits sexually explicit graphics, links to other sites
which Hometown deems offensive, harassment, the use of vulgar or sexually
oriented language, discussion of illegal activities, and/or other activities
that may impair the enjoyment of our community's members.
"We have placed a note of this incident
on your account history and consider this a first warning. We have removed all
the file(s) from your web page/ftp site. A second occurrence will result in
termination of your account with no chance of reactivation."
AOL has made this policy arbitrarily and yet
will not explain it to its subscribers. Child pornography is illegal. Guns and
ammunition are protected under the Second Amendment. Yet AOL chooses to treat
the two identically by refusing to allow any one of its subscribers to engage in
his Constitutional right to keep and bear arms. In doing so, of course, AOL has
followed in the path of a host of smaller Internet Service Providers who have
the same policy.
When the Constitution provides that a practice
is legal and yet someone hinders our ability to exercise that practice, that
someone is setting himself up as an arbiter of our rights. From whom does AOL
get this authority? Well, of course, they are a private business and they can
adopt whatever practice they wish. But when you look at what companies AOL has
swallowed up in the past year and those few that are left that don't have such
arbitrary policies, it is truly frightening.
Unless someone with a lot of capital is willing
to come in to start a new ISP and is going to be open to keeping the Second
Amendment alive and well, there may come a time very soon when gun owners are
simply shut out of every medium of communication.
They have no television sympathetic to them.
Radio, with the exception of short wave, is very restricted. Now many newspapers
and magazines will not take ads for guns and ammunition and if they do,
gun-grabbing organizations are encouraging readers to tear them out. The
Internet was one place, for a short time, gun owners could go to exercise their
Yes, AOL is a business free to make its own
policies. But customers are also free to make their own decisions as well. No
person who respects the Second Amendment should subscribe to AOL unless they
change their policies.
There are millions of gun owners and other
online services that will gladly accept new customers and the cost is in dollar
amounts, not in freedoms.
If computer users take their freedom seriously
and switch to another provider, AOL will feel it in the bottom line. At that
point perhaps they may be willing to discuss the matter with their subscribers.
At that point perhaps AOL will respect and preserve the rights of Americans to
practice the right to keep and bear arms in practical terms. If not, perhaps AOL
should find a more comfortable home elsewhere . . . say . . . in Havana or
Lisa Dean is Vice President for Technology
Policy at the Free Congress Foundation. Reproduced with the permission of NewsMax.com.
All rights reserved.
Commentary for Consideration on the AOL Issue
by Angel Shamaya,
In the interest of balanced reporting, our many
AOL-subscribing members and visitors are likely also aware that there are
discussion boards on AOL where gunfear-afflicted people can access information
they'd not otherwise be exposed to, including that challenging thing that scares
many of them silly: The Truth About Guns. One of our loyal members and a
longtime liberty activist put it this way:
"I'm not leaving AOL until they make an
official statement against guns or until they cut off the discussion boards
related to guns. If every gun owner leaves them, they will have won. Since I
DO post information in AOL's political discussion boards in support of
firearms freedom, my leaving would defeat the purpose of my activist
Both positions, of course, have merit,
therefore we have not taken an official policy stance against AOL as an
organization, nor have we encouraged any AOL members to dump them - though we've
come close, several times. We do not wish to offend our AOL-using members
and visitors, and we are glad AOL's ease of access has enabled people to find
their way here, as well. AOL has done a lot of good by making it ultra
simple for people to access the internet for the first time, and we commend them
for that, heartily.
That said, we find their anti-gun policy
abhorrent to the extreme and contrary to everything this country was founded
upon. We have reviewed and considered their flimsy non-excuses and been met with
no response on multiple occasions when attempting to dialogue for clarification
of their reasonless "reasoning", as well. Their membership is 7 times
the size of the NRA's membership, and their statement to America and their
members about guns is quite a message, indeed. We wouldn't send them a dime
unless it cost them a quarter to process the donation.
What we DO offer is Pro
Gun Internet Access. While AOL is busy censoring good citizens from
being able to have gun-related websites and relegating such information into the
same atrocious category as pedophilia and kiddie porn, we are working our
organization into a position of self-sustainability, and our internet access is
one piece of that puzzle. It makes sense to redirect money you'd be spending
anyway - diverting it to a cause that is true to your own beliefs and
values. For this same reason, we have also created an online
shopping mall offering a great many items you'd be buying elsewhere, and we
ask people who appreciate our work to redirect some of that cash headed for
principle-impoverished corporations into our mission, instead, so we may grow.
God bless AOL for the many good things they've
done to help people turn on and tune in to the internet. SHAME ON THEM for
blocking access to information about self-defense devices their own members use
to protect themselves and their precious family members and loved ones.
- Get your pro-firearm internet access here.
- Shop in a pro-firearm online shopping mall here.
- Join our organization and get a ticket to
possibly win a .50 caliber rifle here.
- Donate to our organization here.
- Head back to our home page here.